What Is That Question Mark in Space? Here’s What We Know — and Don’t Know

Must read

Drowning in a Sea of “Shoulds”: How the Modern Woman Can Find Her Footing and Thrive with Cherillyn

The modern woman is drowning. Not in the literal sense, but in a sea of "shoulds." She should be a high-powered executive, climbing the...

Janna Johnson On Parenting With Or Without Chains

Author of Unf*ck Your Mind shares how to be the perfect mother in a life of chaos and instability. By Sarshar Hosseinnia “Every single generation should...

Jackie Edmundson, CEO Of Stealth Venture Labs, On Why Leaders Should Be Challenging Everything

From challenging clients to internal staff, the most efficient method for leadership is to question everything – which can only be applied effectively by...

Diana Trudic: Shattering Ceilings and Shaping Futures with Astrology

In a remarkable display of talent and perseverance, Diana Trudic has claimed two prestigious accolades in 2024, solidifying her place as one of the...

Space & Cosmos|The Biggest Question Mark in Astronomy? You’re Looking at It.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/18/science/space/question-mark-space-webb-telescope.html

Out There

Close scrutiny of a recent image from the Webb Space Telescope revealed some questionable punctuation.

What looks like an orange question mark sits in the center of a frame that is otherwise filled with stars and galaxies. They are somewhat pixelated from being zoomed in from a larger image.
A near-infrared light image made by the James Webb Space Telescope of actively forming stars, known as Herbig-Haro 46/47, had at the bottom of the frame an apparent question mark.Credit…NASA, ESA, CSA, Joseph DePasquale (STScI), Anton M. Koekemoer (STScI)

Dennis Overbye

The astronomers will tell you it is just an optical illusion, a pair of galaxies caught in the act of mating as seen from the wrong angle. Happens all the time.

In the 1960 and 70s, Halton Arp, an astronomer at Hale Observatories in Southern California, caused a ruckus by asserting that galaxies millions of light-years apart according to conventional cosmological calculations — but which appeared superimposed together in the sky — were interacting locally. His claim cast doubt on the Big Bang theory of the universe. Astronomers now agree that he was wrong.

Now a genuine question mark has been discovered, in the corner of a recent Webb telescope observation of a pair of dust clouds known as Herbig-Haro 46/47 that are in the process of forming into two stars. The discovery made a splash on social media. “Ze space mall information kiosk has been found by JWST,” a commenter joked on X, the site formerly known as Twitter.

Chris Britt, an astronomer at the Baltimore-based Space Telescope Science Institute, which runs the Webb telescope, attempted to explain. “This particular pair is so far away, it’s hard to make out much detail,” he said in an email exchange. “But there are some similar looking galaxy mergers that have been seen closer to us, including this one called II Zwicky 96.”

If you accept the spooky rules of quantum mechanics and the premise, as Einstein disapprovingly put it, that God plays dice with the universe, then you have to accept that chance and randomness are a fundamental bedrock of reality. In such a universe, where the laws of physics have been grinding away for 14 billion years, coincidences are unforeseeable but inevitable.

Image

An image of Herbig-Haro 46/47. The question mark appears at the center-bottom of the frame, to the right of the reddish cloudy material.Credit…NASA, ESA, CSA, Joseph DePasquale (STScI), Anton M. Koekemoer (STScI)

Still, there are times when it’s worth stepping back to listen to “the music,” as Einstein once referred to the beauty and mystery of the cosmos. You are free to consider that question mark as alien graffiti, a comment on both their and our relation to existence. Point being, we’ve barely begun to know anything — that’s why we build telescopes.

Once the Webb has completed its rounds of investigations two decades from now, we might know a bit more about how this bowl of stars works. But we still won’t know why we’re here. That question mark, our profound cosmic ignorance, is one of the great gifts of science.

Dennis Overbye joined The Times in 1998, and has been a reporter since 2001. He has written two books: “Lonely Hearts of the Cosmos: The Story of the Scientific Search for the Secret of the Universe” and “Einstein in Love: A Scientific Romance.” More about Dennis Overbye

More articles

Latest article

Drowning in a Sea of “Shoulds”: How the Modern Woman Can Find Her Footing and Thrive with Cherillyn

The modern woman is drowning. Not in the literal sense, but in a sea of "shoulds." She should be a high-powered executive, climbing the...

Janna Johnson On Parenting With Or Without Chains

Author of Unf*ck Your Mind shares how to be the perfect mother in a life of chaos and instability. By Sarshar Hosseinnia “Every single generation should...

Jackie Edmundson, CEO Of Stealth Venture Labs, On Why Leaders Should Be Challenging Everything

From challenging clients to internal staff, the most efficient method for leadership is to question everything – which can only be applied effectively by...

Diana Trudic: Shattering Ceilings and Shaping Futures with Astrology

In a remarkable display of talent and perseverance, Diana Trudic has claimed two prestigious accolades in 2024, solidifying her place as one of the...

Michella Filipowitz: Leading the Way for Special Needs Support

From sneaking out of her home at 15 to pursue a modeling career in Paris, to becoming a leading advocate for children with disabilities,...