Photoshop Fail in New Pic of Kate Middleton Stokes Conspiracy Theories on Twitter

The royal family dropped a new photo of Kate Middleton and her three kids to celebrate Mother’s Day (March 10 in the United Kingdom), and you’d think it’d have the effect of quieting ongoing conspiracy theories about the Princess of Wales’ whereabouts. But not so much.

Despite the fact that the photo was literally taken by Prince William, fans read all the way into Kate’s missing ring. On top of that, as the Daily Mail reports, it took mere seconds for everyone to notice a pretty glaring photoshop fail on Princess Charlotte’s sleeve.

Just FYI, Kate and William aren’t new to claims of photoshop. Everyone was convinced that things were awry in their Christmas portrait from last year—and while they didn’t put out a statement, a source told Us Weekly they were both “embarrassed” that everyone thought it was edited, and that they “were as shocked as everyone else” by the public’s reaction.

As for Kate’s missing wedding ring and engagement ring in that Mother’s Day Instagram, a Palace source was asked about it and—according to Town & Country’s reporting— “pointed out that the Princess was at home, and the picture was taken by her husband.”

Oh, and before we go: reminder that Kate’s rep spoke out about conspiracy theories regarding her whereabouts at the end of March, telling Page Six that “Kensington Palace made it clear in January the timelines of the princess’ recovery and we’d only be providing significant updates. That guidance stands.”