8 Best Down Comforters of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Yes, down comforters can be a liiiiittle pricey, but this one is def worth the splurge (especially if you’re already obsessed with Brooklinen’s dreamy sheet sets). Made with a silky 100 percent cotton sateen shell, this down cluster-filled duvet features a fluffy baffle-box construction and comes in three different warmth levels—though the all-season (made with 700-fill-power Canadian duck down) is best for year-round comfort.

• Shell material: Cotton sateen
• Fill power: 650 (75% goose and duck down), 700 (80% duck down), or 750 (80% goose down)
• Warmth levels: Lightweight, all-season, or ultra-warm
• Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/Cal king
• Care instructions: Spot clean recommended; dry clean if needed
• Certifications: Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX (guaranteed safe from over 350 harmful substances), Downmark
• Return policy: 30-day returns

THE REVIEW: As one tester writes, “Living in Florida, it is difficult to find a comforter that is light, comfortable, and airy. I have had multiple duvet covers/insert and comforters, and my Brooklinen Down Comforter has been by FAR the best. I cannot recommend product and brand more!!”

Why, yes, you *can* get a sustainably-sourced down-filled comforter without spending hundreds, and this bb is proof. Ideal for year-round use, this cloud-like duvet insert (which comes with a silky Egyptian cotton shell) boasts eight corner loops to keep your cover in place, as well as a baffle-box construction to keep the 750-fill-power down evenly distributed. And though dry cleaning is recommended, reviewers say it holds up fine in the wash.

• Shell material: Egyptian cotton
• Fill power: 750 (80% goose down)
• Warmth level: All-season
• Sizes available: Twin, full, queen, king, Cal king, palatial king
• Care instructions: Dry clean recommended
• Certifications: OEKO-TEX, Responsible Down Standard (RDS), Downpass
• Return policy: Free returns for Prime members

THE REVIEW: “Wow! Amazing quality, especially for the price point,” reads one review. “The warmth is so even. As soon as I opened it, I threw it around to fluff, then put it in the dryer on air dry. A few more fluffs from me, and I put it on my bed. The squares are completely full. 100 percent happy with my purchase.”

Admittedly, a 750-fill-power goose down comforter for less than $150 seems a liiiittle too good to be true—but over 4,600 five-star reviewers on Amazon say it’s the real deal. Available at three warmth levels, this amazingly cheap option has a double-brushed poly-cotton-blend cover and baffle-box construction, and it comes stuffed with responsibly harvested down. Oh, and despite the care instructions, testers claim you can get away with throwing it in the washer and dryer.

• Shell material: Cotton-polyester blend
• Fill power: 750 (75% goose down)
• Warmth levels: Lightweight, all-season, or winter-weight
• Sizes available: Twin, queen, oversized queen, king, oversized king, Cal king, super king
• Care instructions: Dry clean recommended
• Certifications: OEKO-TEX, RDS, Downpass
• Return policy: Free returns for Prime members

THE REVIEW: As one review reads, “I’ve never owned a quality down comforter before. I’ve tried a couple before this one, and there is no comparison. I feel a little spoiled. I will never go back to the poly-filled comforters. So soft and fluffy. Warm but not hot. I’m just in love with this one!”

Yet another surprisingly affordable down comforter: this v good find from Target. Filled with lofty duck down, this box-quilted bb is a great dupe for Brooklinen’s bestselling down comforter, as it features a cotton sateen shell and comes in three different weight options (though again, all-season is best for year-round comforter). Best of all, it has a box-stitch (or “sewn-through”) construction, so you can easily toss this duvet in the wash without worrying about the fill shifting.

• Shell material: Cotton sateen
• Fill power: 600 (75% duck down)
• Warmth levels: Lightweight, all-season, or heavyweight
• Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king
• Care instructions: Machine wash in cold water; tumble dry on low heat
• Certifications: OEKO-TEX, RDS
• Return policy: 365-day return policy

THE REVIEW: “I was looking forward to receiving this product since the moment I ordered it, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!” one review reads. “The down comforter is beautifully made and is perfect to use year-round. It’s not too heavy and at the same time keeps me warm and cozy. I would buy this comforter again and again.”

A 700-fill-power European white goose down duvet for under $300? No, you’re not dreaming. Direct-to-consumer brand Quince is the place to go for premium products without the luxury price tag, and coming in under $300 for the all-season weight, this comforter is such a steal. You’ll love the baffle-box construction, durable double-stitched edges, and the choice of two different warmth options.

• Shell material: Cotton sateen
• Fill power: 700 (down percentage not listed)
• Warmth levels: Lightweight or all-season
• Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king/Cal king
• Care instructions: Machine wash on delicate cycle in cold water; tumble dry on low heat
• Certification: RDS
• Return policy: Free 365-day return policy

THE REVIEW: “Absolutely LOVE this down comforter,” one buyer raves. “So soft and warm but light and airy at the same time. So worth it, especially for the price—it’s great quality. I’ve washed it a few times, and the boxes stay poofy with the down evenly distributed. If you’re thinking about it, just buy it. It really is worth it.”

Calling all hot sleepers: This one’s for you. Featuring a sewn-through construction, the light version of the LaCrosse Down Comforter isn’t as lofty as other options, but it’s smoother and lighter with a breathable cotton twill shell and a variety of color options. It’s also available in medium, extra, and ultra warmth options if ya need something a lil more substantial.

• Shell material: Cotton twill
• Fill power: 500-550 (down percentage not listed)
• Warmth levels: Light, medium, extra, or ultra
• Sizes available: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king/Cal king
• Care instructions: Machine wash on delicate cycle in cold water; tumble dry on low heat
• Certifications: OEKO-TEX, RDS
• Return policy: 30-day return policy with (free for orders of $75+)

THE REVIEW: “Sleeping under this comforter is like sleeping under a puffy, beautiful cloud!” one tester writes. “It feels light as a feather, provides the perfect amount of warmth, and is just the right size. I have used Company Store comforters for years and this is the best one so far!”

With its soft sateen shell, baffle-box construction, double-stitched piping, and 750-fill-power European white down, this duvet insert from Parachute is seeeeriously high quality. According to testers, the all-season option is the ideal weight and fill for staying cozy all year round, and if you tend to sleep hot, you’ll be happy to hear there’s a lightweight version as well.

• Shell material: Cotton sateen
• Fill power: 750 (85% down)
• Warmth levels: Lightweight or all-season
• Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king/Cal king
• Care instructions: Machine wash on delicate cycle in cold water; tumble dry on low heat
• Certifications: OEKO-TEX, RDS
• Return policy: 60-day return policy

THE REVIEW: According to one tester, “I have been looking to replace my duvet insert for literal years. The ones I’ve found are either too crunchy, not warm enough, not lightweight enough, or have a really strong down smell. This one is literally perfect. No crunch, no strong smell, and the perfect weight for Southern California. It’s on the pricier end for me, but I do believe you get what you pay for. This is worth it to me and I know will last many years.”

SOL Organics uses only high-quality sustainable fibers for its products, and this comforter is no exception. Made of GOTS-certified organic cotton and stuffed with ethically-sourced Canadian white down fill, this bb boasts a baffle-box construction and two different weight options—and though it’s pricey, it’s well worth your coin, promise.

• Shell material: Organic cotton
• Fill power: 600 (75% goose down) or 700 (80% goose down)
• Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king/Cal king
• Warmth levels: Summer or all-season
• Care instructions: Spot clean recommended; dry clean if needed
• Certifications: Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), OEKO-TEX, RDS, Downmark
• Return policy: 30-day return policy

THE REVIEW: As one tester writes, “I’m with the other reviewers who have said this is cozy, luxurious, and like sleeping on/under a cloud! I bought the summer fill, and it’s perfect in the moderate climate of Los Angeles—warm at night but super lightweight. I have allergies and am sensitive to chemicals, and this comforter has not bothered me at ALL. It’s wonderfully luxurious and I look forward to snuggling under it and exhaling my stresses before a night of restful sleep.”

The main difference between down comforters and down alternative comforters is the filling found inside. Down comforters are stuffed with material sourced from the soft undercoat of ducks or geese, while down alternative comforters contain either natural or synthetic fills. And while down alternative comforters are a great choice for anyone who wants something hypoallergenic and budget-friendly, down comforters tend to be lighter, fluffier, and better insulators—though they’re also usually pricier and more prone to collecting dust, dander, and other allergens.

When it comes to goose down versus duck down, goose down is usually more expensive than duck down, as it’s considered softer and a better insulator. That said, the difference isn’t *that* significant, and what matters more is getting yourself a comforter made with ethical down (aka feathers sourced from farms that meet certain standards for quality of life). To make sure a down comforter contains ethical fill, you should look for one (or more) of these four certifications: Global Traceable Down Standard (GTDS), Responsible Down Standard (RDS), Downpass, or Downmark.

Down comforters can be pretty $$$, so if you want to get the best option for your bed (and your sleeping habits), then keep these things in mind:

Check out the fill power

Down fill power is a way to measure the quality and effectiveness of down in a duvet, and typically speaking, a higher fill power = a fluffier bed. High-fill-power down is lightweight and warm but not heavy, and that’s because fluffier down has higher insulating power, which means it requires less material (and fewer feather fibers) to fill the same space. When shopping for a down comforter, it’s best to find one with a fill power of at least 500—especially if you’re looking to stay cozy.

Find the right warmth level

Speaking of cozy! Down duvets are notorious for being pretty warm…which isn’t exactly great for hot sleepers. But the good news is that many down comforters come in different warmth options, such as lightweight, heavyweight, and all-season. A comforter’s warmth is determined by a balance of fill power and fill weight, with fill weight referring to the amount of fill put into the duvet cover. And JSYK, a high fill weight doesn’t necessarily mean a high fill power (yep, it’s confusing). Duvets with high fill powers actually tend to have lower fill weights, so don’t assume a heavier duvet is going to be warmer.

Know your weight preference

The weight of your comforter can make all the difference when it comes to getting a good night’s rest. You can usually find comforters available in lightweight, heavyweight, or all-season weight levels. Having a heavier down comforter has the same benefits of a weighted blanket—it can help reduce feelings of anxiety and offer calming effects on a restless body. Plus, they’re ideal for cool sleepers. However, if you tend to toss and turn throughout the night (or just simply don’t like the feeling of additional weight), a lightweight comforter may be best for you. These are more suit for warmer months and hot sleepers. As for all-season duvets, it’s exactly what it sounds like—comforters that are more suitable for year-round use, thanks to temperature-regulating fill.

Consider the care instructions

Since most of these down comforter picks are meant to be put inside a duvet cover, they typically only need to get washed every four to six months. However! Spills can and do happen, and getting your duvet professionally laundered can be expensive (not to mention a pain). If you have pets or kids (or just happen to be v spill-prone), consider skipping the spot-clean-only or dry-clean-only comforters for something you can easily toss in the wash at home.

As you probably know, Cosmo’s lifestyle team spends all day, every day scouring the internet, testing products, and reading reviews so we can bring you the type of high-quality content we’d want for ourselves (and our standards are preeeetty darn high, TBH).

It’s also really important to us that each of our shopping articles adheres to the 15 Percent Pledge, and we try to make sure the products we feature are good for both you and our planet. If we wouldn’t buy something for ourselves, we sure as heck won’t recommend it to you—and we’re always gonna keep it really, really real. Pinky swear.